***** 5- stars
Emery and August grew up on the island of Saoirse along with Lily and Dutch. August’s family owned the orchard that was central to the island’s economy. When a fire breaks out and nearly destroys it and Lily is murdered after the high school graduation party, the island residents including August’s uncle, the police chief, accuse him of killing her.
When the story opens, August is returning to the island with his mother’s ashes after they left fourteen years ago. He mentions that he did something terrible, and we wonder if he really did kill Lily. As he meets up again with Emery, his high school sweetheart who is now seeing Dutch, old feelings reunite, but things have changed. Emery can no longer trust him, although she still loves him.
As the book progresses, we learn of the supernatural elements on the island and how Emery’s grandmother and Lily’s grandmother practice witchcraft.
I enjoyed this book after reading an advanced reader’s copy of The Unmaking of June Farrow, also by this author that I found even better. If you like mysteries with supernatural elements, you’ll enjoy both these books.

